Blurred Lines Indeed: Are Court Cases Rewriting The Rules?

by Cari Cole

 

Well, another week in music copyright hell that made history. The copyright case of Blurred Lines has unfortunately irrevocably left it’s mark.

The New York Times said “On Tuesday, a federal jury in Los Angeles concluded that Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams, the performer and primary songwriter-producer of the 2013 pop hit “Blurred Lines,” committed copyright infringement by using elements of the 1977 Marvin Gaye song “Got to Give It Up” in their composition without proper credit. The “non-musician” jury awarded Mr. Gaye’s family approximately $7.3 million, a combination of profits from the song and damages.” How is this right? For the full article provided in the links below.

How ironic is it that the name of the song causing the heated controversy and disruption to the already blurred lines of music copyright, is aptly titled “Blurred Lines.” It couldn’t have been any more of a blurred lines case.

Is the already slippery sliding slope of music copyright now being rewritten by such copyright court cases? There was a time when it was clear – melody and lyrics, 8 bars of either was copyright infringement. There was no such thing as copyright claims for “grooves” or “production elements” or the “feel” of a sound recording. What comes next, chord progressions?

As a songwriter and music maker, the problem with the “blurred lines” case is now we have more to worry about and that can sure crimp one’s songwriting session. What to do?

How the heck can a songwriter not be influenced by the music we hear throughout our lives? Is what we think is an original melody really new or is it just lingering in our brain from the past? How can you possibly have heard all the songs in the universe to know whether yours is original or not?

You can’t. You just have to write, stay positive, don’t steal music and pray that you’ll never fall into a situation like that. And if it does happen, it’s easy – just settle quickly out of court, don’t be greedy and take your ego completely out of the situation. Take a lesson from Sam Smith and his team who immediately granted songwriting credit to Tom Petty and Jeff Lynne for an unintentional copyright infringement. That’s class (see article in Rolling Stone below).

Thankfully, big cases like these are fairly infrequent (most settle out of court). If people would just focus on creating great music instead of who to sue.

Now can we all get back to making great music and trusting our instincts and integrity. You’re as good as your word people!

Read up on the Blurred Lines court case:
New York Times
Billboard
Huffington Post

Sam Smith + Tom Petty’s copyright case (settled out of court amicably):
Rolling Stone

Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Share this post

Categories

Hi, I’m Cari Cole.

You’ve got talent, but you want to become great at it. You’re in the right place! My mission is to help you refine your unique artist vision to bring to the world.

About Cari Cole

Cari Cole is the CEO / Founder of caricole.com and CCVM: Label Without Walls. She is a Holistic Vocal Coach, Artist Development Expert, A&R Director, and Songwriter based in New York City helping artists for the past 38 years. She is a mentor for Women in Music and The Association of Independent Music Publishers.

Her latest venture, CCVM a label services company, provides artists with a seamless path from creation to completion. After 30+ years of observing the overwhelm and challenges that artists face, Cari pulled together the best top creative professionals and designed a new approach to supporting our artists.

Disclaimer:
The information provided on Cari Cole's website is informational only and should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health problem or disease. Those seeking personal medical advice should consult with a licensed physician. Always seek the advice of your doctor or other qualified health provider regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on Cari Cole's website. If you think you may have a medical emergency, call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room immediately.

Worried About Losing Your
Voice During a Performance?

In a few minutes you'll learn:

  • Where your voice rates on the vocal health scale
  • How to realign your voice and regain vocal health
  • How to stay healthy and vocally fit throughout your career

Get Your Free Vocal Health Quiz

A Gift from Holistic Vocal Coach, Cari Cole.

Assess your vocal health + get my proven techniques and holistic remedies to support your vocal health.

Announcing a brand new experience...

Cari Signature_White

Presents:

VOCAL PERFORMANCE CIRCLE

8 weeks to your best performance, ever.

Ease. Execution. Excellence.

Cari Cole Vocal Coach Signature

free vocal workshop

The Power of the
Singing Voice

Thursday, May 4th at 2:30pm ET
*Limited seats available

Held LIVE on

Untitled design (3)

WORLD VOICE DAY

SAVe up to

50% OFF

ENDS APRIL 17!

Love yourself with a special gift...

VALENTINE’S DAY

SAVE UP TO

30% Off

ENDS FEBRUARY 15!

CCVM
Monthly Musician

MEMBERSHIP

CCVM

VOCAL
EXERCISES

CCVM

PROGRAMS

with Cari Cole

CCVM

PRIVATE
SESSIONS

with Cari Cole

Cari Cole Vocal Coach Signature
Cari Signature_White

Black Friday

SAVE UP TO

50% OFF

ENDS NOVEMBER 28!

CCVM
Monthly Musician

MEMBERSHIP

CCVM

VOCAL
EXERCISES

CCVM

PROGRAMS

with Cari Cole

CCVM

PRIVATE
SESSIONS

with Cari Cole

Back by popular demand!

Cari Cole Presents:

VOCAL FREEDOM CIRCLE

20 minutes a day.
3 months.
Your best voice ever.

*Program starts February 7 - April 10, 2024

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions